不同干旱程度下社会规范对农牧交错区社会-生态系统的影响
作者:
作者单位:

作者简介:

通讯作者:

中图分类号:

基金项目:

国家自然科学基金面上项目(52270189);陕西省教育厅专项科研计划项目(21JK0213)


The effects of social norms on the social-ecological systems in agro-pastoral ecotone under different drought degrees
Author:
Affiliation:

Fund Project:

The National Natural Science Foundation of China (General Program, Key Program, Major Research Plan)

  • 摘要
  • |
  • 图/表
  • |
  • 访问统计
  • |
  • 参考文献
  • |
  • 相似文献
  • |
  • 引证文献
  • |
  • 文章评论
    摘要:

    全球气候变暖导致干旱事件频发,干旱已经严重威胁农牧交错区社会-生态系统的健康发展。与此同时,受超载过牧干扰草原生态环境日益恶化,农牧交错区社会-生态系统面临巨大压力。为维持农牧交错区社会-生态系统的可持续发展,国务院于2002年、2012年和2016年相继实行草原禁牧政策、第一轮草原生态奖补政策和第二轮草原生态奖补政策。然而,政策实施以来违规放牧现象长期存在,农户违规放牧使草原生态系统受到影响,导致禁牧政策和草原生态奖补政策未能有效发挥作用,农牧交错区社会-生态系统依然面临系统崩溃风险。基于此,以草场沙化严重区域宁夏盐池县为例,基于多主体建模与仿真方法(Agent-based model,ABM)模拟农户放牧行为决策过程,分析不同干旱程度下,执法力度和邻里效应等社会规范对农牧交错区社会-生态系统的影响机制。为更合理的展示和模拟农牧交错区实际,本文结合2021年盐池县问卷调研数据、社会经济统计数据、部分文献数据以及草原监测数据等,对ABM模型中的参数进行设定,构建了用于模拟干旱干扰下农牧交错区社会-生态系统模型。结果显示:(1)干旱影响下农户收入呈先上升后下降的趋势,且农户收入最终低于初始状态。同时,随干旱概率的增加,草地生态系统退化趋势加剧。(2)总体而言,当草场面临干旱等自然灾害影响时,执法力度的增加并未有效保证社会-生态系统健康发展。具体表现为,当干旱来临时随执法力度的增加,农户收入能够维持在稳定的区间内,执法力度对农户收入产生的影响较小。并且,在不同干旱程度下执法力度的增强未能有效制止违规放牧行为,导致草地生态系统继续退化。(3)强邻里效应能够很大程度上影响农户行为决策,进而对农牧交错区社会-生态系统产生影响。当农户行为决策受周围农户影响很大时(即强邻里效应下),农户更容易实施违规放牧,致使草地生态系统受超载放牧和干旱影响,造成草地生态系统恶化。而从短期来看违规放牧导致农户生产成本大幅降低,从而提升了农户生产效益,增加农户收入。然而长远而言,强邻里效应下大量农户违规放牧,致使草地生态系统达到最大载畜量,草地生态系统恶化,农户转为舍饲养殖,农户生产经济效益下降,农户收入逐渐下降。

    Abstract:

    Global warming has led to frequent droughts, which have become a serious threat to the sustainabledevelopment of social-ecological systems in the agro-pastoral ecotone. At the same time, the grassland ecological environment is deteriorating as a result of overloading and overgrazing, and the social-ecological systems in the agro-pastoral ecotone are under significant stress. In order to maintain the sustainable development of the social-ecological systems in the agro-pastoral ecotone, the State Council implemented the grassland grazing ban policy, the first round of grassland ecological subsidy policy, and the second round of grassland ecological subsidy policy in 2002, 2012, and 2016, respectively. However, since the implementation of the policy, the phenomenon of illegal grazing has existed for a long time, and the grassland ecosystem has been affected by illegal grazing by farmers, which has led to the failure of the forbidden grazing policy and the grassland ecological reward and subsidy policy to play an effective role, and the social-ecological systems in the agro-pastoral ecotone are still facing the risk of system collapse. Based on this, this paper takes Yanchi County of Ningxia, a serious area of grassland desertification, as an example, simulates the decision-making process of farmers' grazing behavior based on ABM(Agent-based model), and analyzes the influence mechanism of social norms, such as law enforcement and neighborhood effect, on the social-ecological system in the agro-pastoral ecotone under different drought levels.To demonstrate and simulate the actuality of the agro-pastoral ecotone, this paper combines the questionnaire research data, social-economic statistical data, part of the literature data, and grassland monitoring data of Yanchi County in 2021, sets the parameters in the ABM model, and constructs the social-ecological system model used to simulate the agro-pastoral ecotone under the disturbance of drought. The results show that (1) The income of farmers under the influence of drought shows a tendency of increasing and then decreasing, and the income of farmers is finally lower than the initial state. Meanwhile, the degradation trend of grassland ecosystem increased with the increase of drought probability. (2) Overall, when the grassland faces the impact of natural disasters such as drought, the increase in law enforcement has not been effective in ensuring the healthy development of the social-ecological system. Specifically, when drought comes with the increase of law enforcement efforts, the income of farmers can be maintained in a stable range, and the impact of law enforcement efforts on farmers' income is small. Moreover, the increase in enforcement efforts under different drought levels failed to effectively stop illegal grazing behavior, resulting in the continued degradation of grassland ecosystems. (3) The potent neighborhood effect can significantly influence the behavior and decision-making of farmers, and subsequently exert an impact on the social-ecological system in the agro-pastoral ecotone. When the behavioral decisions of farmers are profoundly affected by the surrounding farmers (that is, under the potent neighborhood effect), farmers are more prone to undertake illegal grazing, causing the influence of overgrazing and drought on the grassland ecosystem and leading to the deterioration of the grassland ecosystem. In the short term, illegal grazing leads to a notable reduction in farmers' production costs, thereby enhancing farmers' production efficiency and increasing farmers' income. However, in the long run, under the potent neighborhood effect, a large number of farmers engaging in illegal grazing results in the maximum livestock carrying capacity of the grassland ecosystem, the deterioration of the grassland ecosystem, farmers resorting to indoor feeding, the decline in the economic efficiency of farmers' production, and the gradual decrease in farmers' income.

    参考文献
    相似文献
    引证文献
引用本文

侯彩霞,尹小明,王萌萌.不同干旱程度下社会规范对农牧交错区社会-生态系统的影响.生态学报,2024,44(22):10031~10043

复制
分享
文章指标
  • 点击次数:
  • 下载次数:
  • HTML阅读次数:
  • 引用次数: