自然资源保护对参与者多维福祉的影响——以黄河源头玛多牧民为例
作者:
作者单位:

青海民族大学公共管理学院,华中农业大学土地管理学院,青海民族大学

作者简介:

通讯作者:

中图分类号:

基金项目:

教育部人文社科青年项目(12YJCZH105);教育部春晖计划(Z2012039);国家社科基金项目(13CJY016);国家自然科学基金项目(71373095,71341040);湖北省高校优秀中青年科技创新团队(T201012)


Herdsman's multidimensional well-being in response of natural resources protection in the source region of the Yellow River, China: case study based on household investigation in Maduo County
Author:
Affiliation:

College of Land Management,Huazhong Agricultural University,College of Land Management,Huazhong Agricultural University,School of Public Administration and Policy,Qinghai University for nationality,Xining

Fund Project:

  • 摘要
  • |
  • 图/表
  • |
  • 访问统计
  • |
  • 参考文献
  • |
  • 相似文献
  • |
  • 引证文献
  • |
  • 文章评论
    摘要:

    受气候变化和人类活动的影响,三江源生态系统脆弱且退化严重,为保护日益退化严重的三江源生态系统,2005年国家在三江源地区实施了全面的生态保护战略.结合森的能力框架和马斯洛层次需要理论探讨了福祉的内涵,构建了福祉评价体系,运用参与式农村评估方法,在对黄河源头玛多县159户牧民进行住户问卷调研的基础上,用模糊评价法和层次分析法确定权重,评价了玛多牧民参与生态保护前后的福祉变化.结果表明:(1)自然资源保护中人类福祉的内涵,指人类在生态系统生产和利用中为实现美好的生活、健康、体验、各种社会关系、归属感、尊重和实现自我价值等而选择各种生活的自由和能力即是人类福祉,贫穷指能力和发展的受限即福祉的下降.(2)福祉是多维的、递阶的,低阶的功能维度的实现程度将影响到高阶的功能维度的实现,并最终影响个体的福祉.(3)玛多牧民在参与生态保护移民中个体的能力值由5.061变为4.708,即福祉受到了一定程度的损失,是因生计能力的限制,致使收入和消费的低阶需求未能有效满足,并影响了生活实现和自我价值的实现、归属感等高阶功能的实现,更是由于在参与生态保护移民中不能选择继续生活在草原,能力和发展权受到了限制,进而导致福祉下降,是生计能力不足导致的收入贫困、知识性贫困和生态型贫困的综合结果.(4)聚焦只能强烈依赖于草地生态系统放牧而生存的牧民的福祉,了解并深入分析牧民的生态保护行为响应机制和动力,建立福祉损失和牧户生计能力提高为基础的科学的生态补偿机制才能实现生态保护和社会福祉均衡及最大化.(5)以提高人类能力为核心,促进牧民生计多样化以改善牧民的福祉和激励牧民主动积极地参与生态保护和建设,在可持续发展的综合理念下制定自然资源保护和管理规划,才能最终促使有效的生态系统保护-提高人类福祉-发展的多赢局面的实现.

    Abstract:

    Sanjiangyuan Region is the headstream area of three main rivers in Asia, i.e. Yangtze River, Yellow River, and Lancangjiang River (Mekong). It is an important ecological barrier of the local and regional environmental security and sustainable development, not only for China but also for the southeastern Asian, In recent decades, however, grasslands in Sanjiangyuan Region were seriously disturbed or destroyed by both global climate change and human activities, which led to sharp decrease of nourishing capacity of source water and serious environmental problems of the lower reaches. Since 2005, Chinese government began to implement a series of activities, e.g. ‘Returning Grazing Land to Grassland Project’ and ‘Ecological Migration Project’, in Sanjiangyuan Region to alleviate the situation of grassland degradation, and gradually restore and protect the ecological environment. The success of such projects in Sanjiangyuan Region depends largely on local herdsman's active response, support and participation,however, the herdsmen's well-being improved or nondecreased is the key to the effective implementation of ecological protection and herdsmen's participation willingness directly influences the accomplishment efficiency and sustainability of ecological protection.Based on the framework of Sen's function and Maslow's hierarchy of needs, this paper states the connotation of the well-being and constructs the evaluation system of well-being. The participatory rural appraisal methods were employed to survey the 159 herder household in Maduo County in the source region of the Yellow River. Based on the questionnaire survey, the fuzzy and analytic hierarchy process were used to determine the weights, this paper evaluates the well-being of Maduo herdsman before and after they participated in the protection of natural resources, then analysis the behavior response. The results indicate: (1) The connotation of human well-being in the protection of natural resources is that the freedom and ability of human when they choose their life, while they want to achieve a better life, health, experience, a variety of social relationships, a sense of belonging, respect and self-worth in the production and utilization of human ecosystem. Poverty refers to the limited capacity and development; it also means the decline in well-being. (2) Well-being is multidimensional and hierarchical, and the degree of realization of low-level functional dimension will affect the realization of the high-level functionality dimension, ultimately affects the well-being of the individual. (3) The individual value of Maduo herdsman in the migrant of ecological protection deceased from 5.061 to 4.708, the loss of well-being is caused by constraints of livelihoods capacity, and results in low-level demand of income and consumption cannot be satisfied, then affects the achievement of high-level function such as the realization of life implementation and self-worth and a sense of belonging. Especially the migrant whom part cited in the protection of natural resources cannot continue to live in the grasslands, the ability and development right has been limited, which led to the decline of well-being. (4) We should pay attention to the well-being of the herdsman, whom strongly dependent on grazing in the grassland ecosystem, then understand and in-depth analysis of the response mechanisms and driving force of herders' ecological protection behavior, and establish scientific ecological compensation mechanism which based on well-being losses, that the ecological protection and social well-being will be balanced and maximized. (5) For the purpose of enhance human capabilities and promote the diversification of herdsman' livelihoods to improve the well-being and incentive the herders actively involved in ecological protection, the natural resource conservation and management planning should be formulated under the concept of sustainable development, which can achieve the effective ecosystem protection -improve human well-being -the development win-win situation.

    参考文献
    相似文献
    引证文献
引用本文

李惠梅,张雄,张俊峰,张安录,杨海镇.自然资源保护对参与者多维福祉的影响——以黄河源头玛多牧民为例.生态学报,2014,34(22):6767~6777

复制
分享
文章指标
  • 点击次数:
  • 下载次数:
  • HTML阅读次数:
  • 引用次数: